WEF Discussions — Now on LinkedIn!

WEF is pleased to announce the creation of free LinkedIn groups associated with its technical discussion forum topics. Through these LinkedIn groups, members will be able to view and participate in discussions, as well as communicate with one another via direct messages. Share your experiences and knowledge, ask questions and respond to other discussions as frequently as you like!

You must have a LinkedIn profile to join a LinkedIn group; you can create your profile here. If you already have a LinkedIn profile, all you need to do is submit a request to join one or all of the following groups:

Water Environment Federation (Main) | Biosolids | Collection Systems | Nutrients | Stormwater 
Utility Management | Water Reuse | Water for Jobs | Watershed Management | Laboratory Practices 

RSS Feed Print
seeding high strength BOD's
Donald Tucker
Posted: Wednesday, April 14, 2010 8:30 AM
Joined: 1/4/2010
Posts: 5

Hello,  we have an industrial user which uses waste potato starch in their process.  They have very high BOD's.  We normally don't seed their samples when performing BOD's and typically get results in the 5,000 to 10,000 range.  We recently split a sample with an outside lab who did seed the samples and they got results which were about 2X higher than ours.  My question is whether the reason for lower BOD's is that the our BOD dilutions are biology limited.  That is there is not enough natural seed to take up the required BOD?  We are seeing final DO's greater than 1 mg/l on our dilutions so this dosen't seem real possible, but just wondering.


Thank You.

Posted: Wednesday, April 14, 2010 10:28 AM
Joined: 12/31/2009
Posts: 40

I would say, yes you need to seed the samples.  I think the starch will have some chemical activity of its own and oxidize even without the presence of the bugs.  At the very least i would set up a batch or two of the samples with seed and without seed to compare in your facility the differences in the two.  I would not put too much stock in a one time doubled result from a different lab.  Interlab comparison on anything other than G:Ga (or some other stable chemical) for BOD is about as close to meaningless as you can get without being insulting.

Perry Brake
Posted: Wednesday, April 14, 2010 10:45 AM
Joined: 12/16/2009
Posts: 69

There is a tendency to think that the BOD of a sample is somehow related to the need to seed (e.g., high BOD, no need to seed).  You can have very high BOD, and essentially no seed.  Consider a GGA sample that you prepared to be somewhere between 5000 and 10000 (more or less what you are testing, Donald, except that your sample contains primarily starch rather than glucose and glutamic acid).  Would you seed that GGA sample?  Of course you would.


The best rule to follow is that unless you KNOW the sample already has sufficient seed (for example, as a domestic influent normally does), you must seed.


So why do you get ANY oxygen depletion on the potato waste sample?  There are always sufficient bacteria floating around where the sample was taken and in your lab to provide some depletion.  I once inspected a lab that never seeded the GGA sample and got an average in the 180s with good precision.  Doesn't say much for the cleanliness of the lab!

Posted: Wednesday, April 14, 2010 11:14 AM

I see your point Perry.  My opinion was always to seed these samples because the industrial process which the starch is subjected to is high temp and pressure before it is sent to our sanitary system.  I just did not think it was plausible for any bacteria to survive, however because we were getting decent depletions w/o seeding we stoped seeding.  Given the importance in getting a representative BOD value for which to bill this industry, I think our practice now will be to seed, however I think for the sake of curriosity I will also do what dsmith suggests and compare some seeded vs unseeded samples.


Thanks for all your help.

Brent Dickey
Posted: Thursday, April 15, 2010 8:44 AM
Joined: 9/28/2009
Posts: 18



Please post the results of your seeded vs unseeded BODs for us. We have an ice cream plant and we never seeded the BOD for their discharge. Reading the responses here I can see that we should have.

Perry Brake
Posted: Thursday, April 15, 2010 2:21 PM
Joined: 12/16/2009
Posts: 69

Good plan, Donald, to compare seeded to unseeded results.  If you would like to put a small wager on the outcome, let me know!



Donald Tucker
Posted: Thursday, April 15, 2010 3:27 PM
Joined: 1/4/2010
Posts: 5

I'd be more than happy to post the results.  As for placing any kind of a wager with Perry on anthing having to do with BOD results, I'd have to be nutshappy





Posted: Sunday, June 26, 2011 9:21 PM
THX that's a great aswner!
Posted: Sunday, June 26, 2011 11:02 PM
Ppl like you get all the barnis. I just get to say thanks for he answer.
Posted: Monday, June 27, 2011 1:53 AM
Geez, that's ubneelivalbe. Kudos and such.
Posted: Monday, June 27, 2011 2:59 PM
Kudos to you! I hadn't thuohgt of that!